Survey and Evaluation of Ontologies in Materials Science

This document is a research article that surveys and evaluates ontologies used in the field of Materials Science and Engineering (MSE). It aims to assist domain experts in selecting appropriate ontologies for various applications by providing a comprehensive analysis of sixty selected ontologies. The paper outlines the methodology employed for the evaluation, which includes gathering expert insights, establishing quality requirements, and defining evaluation metrics. It discusses the challenges faced by MSE professionals in identifying suitable ontologies due to inadequate metadata and limited availability of comprehensive evaluations. The findings include statistical data on ontology reuse and key metrics that highlight the strengths and weaknesses of the analyzed ontologies. The document emphasizes the importance of a thorough review to guide experts in their decision-making processes regarding ontology selection, and it presents a structured approach to ontology evaluation that can enhance usability and relevance in MSE applications.