This research article discusses the intersection of artificial intelligence (AI) and advertising, focusing on the implications of AI productivity gains in advertising development and measurement. It outlines the potential risks associated with relying solely on AI for ad creation and evaluation, particularly concerning the preservation of human creativity and the effectiveness of advertising. The article emphasizes the importance of integrating human intelligence (HI) with AI to enhance the creative process and ensure that advertising remains impactful. It presents a vision for AI ad evaluation tools that are more aligned with human creativity, aiming to improve the effectiveness of advertising without compromising the unique artistic elements that define successful campaigns. The findings are supported by a dataset of 18,000 ads used to train the AI ad evaluation solution, Creative|Spark AI, highlighting the necessity of human response metrics and diverse ad features in accurately predicting human reactions to advertisements. The article concludes with a call for a balanced approach that leverages both AI and human insights in the advertising research process.